Striking the Right Balance: Evaluating Benefits and Risks in Theatre Education Research for Children's Social-Emotional Learning

 The importance of theatre education in enhancing children's skills, especially in social-emotional learning (SEL), is increasingly being recognized (MUHS, 2020). However, conducting research involving humans, especially minors, requires considering potential risks and benefits carefully. This study aims to explore the potential dangers associated with a research project that analyzes the impact of theatre instruction on students' social and emotional learning.

Potential Risks in Theatre Education Research

It is crucial to investigate the positive impact of theatre education on social and emotional learning (SEL). However, it is equally essential to acknowledge the potential risks associated with different research methods (Trochim, 2006). These risks can be categorized into four areas: psychological stress, privacy and confidentiality, coercion and informed consent, and ethical concerns.

1. Psychological Stress: Engaging in theatrical activities can cause performance anxiety, especially in individuals who are already prone to stage fright (Trochim 2006). This nervousness may have a detrimental impact on their experience while preventing them from collecting correct data. Furthermore, group dynamics and peer pressure within theatre activities may cause stress or discomfort for participants who feel forced to comply or perform in specific ways (Data collection strategies II: Qualitative study, n.d.). Furthermore, addressing emotions and personal experiences as part of SEL development may result in unanticipated disclosures that participants must be prepared to process or disclose publicly, thus leading to emotional discomfort (MUHS, 2020).

2. When conducting research using interviews, focus groups, and observations, privacy and confidentiality concerns should be considered, especially when students share sensitive information. The participants must understand how their data will be used, anonymized, and stored under ethical guidelines outlined in the Belmont Report (1978). Even after anonymization, it may still be possible to identify individual facts about participants' experiences or performances within a small group or community setting. Therefore, it is essential to implement techniques that can mitigate these risks.

3. When conducting research involving children, obtaining informed consent from their parents or guardians is essential. The process of seeking permission should include a clear description of the research objectives, methodology, and potential risks, all in line with ethical research practices. Also, it is imperative to emphasize that participation is voluntary, and students can withdraw at any point without facing any negative consequences. This ensures no coercion, especially in educational settings where power dynamics may come into play (Belmont Report, 1978).

4. In the study of drama applied to content-based training, MUHS (2020) emphasized the importance of designing inclusive research activities and techniques that avoid bias towards individual participants. It is crucial to ensure that the benefits of participation in the research outweigh the potential risks to participants, adhere to ethical research guidelines, and prioritize the student population's well-being.

It is essential to consider the risks associated with drama-based training. However, Cohen-Schwartz and Abrami (2011) concluded that the advantages of adopting theatrical instruction outweigh the risks. Their research shows drama-based training can enhance student engagement, learning, and social-emotional growth.

It is essential to consider the risks associated with drama-based training. However, Cohen-Schwartz and Abrami (2011) concluded that the advantages of adopting theatrical instruction outweigh the risks. Their research shows drama-based training can enhance student engagement, learning, and social-emotional growth.

It is essential to identify and manage any potential risks in your research proposal to prioritize ethical research methods and protect the safety and well-being of the chosen student group. To minimize these hazards, you should use techniques such as obtaining informed consent, preserving confidentiality, and reducing stress. The aim is to conduct educational research that promotes knowledge while ensuring the positive and secure participation of the selected student population.

References:

Belmont Report. (1978). Ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research. The National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/belmont-report/read-the-belmont-report/index.html

Cohen-Schwartz, J., & Abrami, P. C. (2011). The effects of drama-based instruction on student engagement, learning, and social-emotional development. Review of Educational Research, 81(1), 104-130. https://scholarworks.umt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=12669&context=etd

Data collection strategies II: Qualitative research. (n.d.). California State University. http://web.csulb.edu/~msaintg/ppa696/696quali.htm

MUHS, A.R.(2020).DRAMA APPLIED TO CONTENT-BASED INSTRUCTION IN TION IN ELEMENTARY EDUCATION. https://scholarworks.umt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=12669&context=etd

Trochim, W. M. K, (2006). Descriptive statistics. conjoint.ly. http://www.socialresearchmethods.net/kb/statdesc.php

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Drama as Dialogue: Fostering Critical Thinking Through Performance

When teaching students about critical thinking, it is crucial to use reliable sources. According to Fasko and Fair (2020), essential components of critical thinking include theory, development, education, and assessment. Kharbach (2023) has identified eight necessary components for critical thinking, which educators can use to plan engaging conversations and problem-solving activities that help students understand the fundamentals. The drama theatre provides an engaging and dynamic platform to demonstrate the use of critical thinking. For instance, when teaching acting to my students, I often show them a scene from a renowned play or film, like Shakespeare's "Hamlet." Then, I encourage my students to analyze the character's choices and the consequences of those choices, which helps them comprehend how critical thinking can be applied in practical contexts (Fasko & Fair, 2020). After watching a scenario, I would initiate a conversation by asking questions such as, ...
Read more

Beyond the Script: Cultivating Diverse Voices and Learning Styles in Theatre Education

It is crucial to consider the diverse needs of learners in modern education. Many authors, including Bray (2005), Flores, Monroy, and Fabela (2015), Howard and Christian (2002), and McFarland-McDaniels (n.d.), have identified several effective ways of creating an inclusive learning environment. Among these methods, differentiated instruction stands out as an efficient approach. This approach involves modifying teaching methods, content, and assessment to cater to the various learning needs of students within the same classroom. Differentiated education in a drama class can take various forms, such as assignment options and flexible grouping. The assignment options can be customized to cater to students' different learning styles and abilities. For instance, students could perform a scene, write a reflective essay about a play, create a visual storyboard, or compose music related to the theater they studied. This approach, as described by Howard and Christian (2002), allows students...
Read more